They're real push-up liner - Żelowy eyeliner

Please for the love of GOD bring it back!

This is by far my most favorite liner. I can't find anything else that will take its place and I'm running out of places to find it... I'm down to like my last few twists. Idk why you guy's discontinued this but pls reconsider and bring it back. I'd buy a case of these easily

Benefit Push up liner

Hi I've been using this for the past 8 years it's been part of my daily life, running through all the stores in South Africa wondering why can't I find my fav liner and please please please bring it back on the shelves

Miss it

When I tell you that I've tried so many liners, and my eyeliner has never looked at consistently good as it did when this product was available. Please make this available again. I'm begging you!

PLEASE BRING IT BACK!

Not sure if it's seasonal or not but please bring this eyeliner back! Seriously the best I've ever used! Yes I know there's some frustrations with loosing some of the product if it comes out of the tube and you don't need it and can't put it back (honestly this would be amazing if it can be fixed)... BUT.... the product as a whole is amazing! I love that it doesn't budge, that it's matte, I love the applicator tip and how close I can get to my lash line... love love love this eyeliner. Please bring it back :'(

Bring it back!!

WHY would you stop making this. Tried all your other liners and many high-end brands and nothing works. This is easy to apply, plus I have oily eyelids and this does not budge all day. Do not listen to the negative reviews - so many of us love it and there is nothing else as good! I never write reviews, so PLEASE LISTEN!

Please bring it back!

This eyeliner has been my favorite for 7 years! Please bring it back! Nothing else on the market compares to this formula! I live in San Francisco where it's cold and damp all year long and this eyeliner never budged, never smeared, it was just perfection! Please bring it back!

This was my favorite bring it back!!!!

The gel liner was so intense and so easy to use!!! I get teary eyed easily because of all my allergies and it wouldn't dissolve. Please bring it back and take my money

Please bring it back!

I cannot find a gel liner with or without a brush that is as smooth and long lasting as this one was. It was the only one like it on the market (the smash box version was not good) please bring it back at least in black and brown!!!

This is my favorite eyeliner

I have used this eye liner for over 4 years now. I am so upset they are out of stock or maybe discontinued. They last for over 24 hrs and I love the texture. PLEASE PLEASE get them back in store!

BRING IT BACK

I CANT LIVE WITHOUT THIS EYELINER!!!!!! Please bring this back!

This is god tier

I have never found an eyeliner this good Please bring it back

Please bring this back

Please bring this back. I haven't been able to find an eyeliner that even compares ever since you took it off the shelves.